Monday, November 10, 2014

GAME ON — My New Column in the Wall Street Journal

For a while I’ve had the secret ambition to write a regular newspaper column. At one time I thought I could write a chess column; at other times I thought that Dan Simons and I could write a series of essays on social science and critical thinking. Last year I suggested to the Wall Street Journal a column on games. They turned me down then, but a few weeks ago I gently raised the idea again and the editors kindly said they would give it a try. So I’m excited to say that the first one is out in this past weekend’s paper (page C4, in the Review section), and also online here.

The column is about Dan Harrington's famous "squeeze play" during the final table of the 2004 World Series of Poker main event. Here's how ESPN covered the hand (you can see in the preview frame that he was making a big bluff with his six-deuce):


There were several things about this hand that I would have mentioned if I had the space. First, a couple of important details for understanding the action:

  • Greg Raymer, the ultimate winner, started the hand with about $7.9 million in chips. Josh Arieh, who finished third, had $3.9 million. Harrington had $2.3 million, the second smallest stack at the table.
  • Seven players remained in the tournament (of the starting field of about 2500) when this hand was played. At a final table like this, the prize payouts escalate substantially with each player eliminated. This might explain why Harrington put in half of his chips, rather than all of them. In case he got raised or called and lost the hand, he would still have a bit left to play with, and could hope to move up the payout chart if other players busted before he did.
  • David Williams, the eventual runner-up, was actually dealt the best hand of anyone: he had ace-queen in the big blind. But facing a raise, a call, and a re-raise in front of him, he chose to fold, quite reasonably assuming that at least one of the players already in the hand would have had him beat, and perhaps badly—e.g., holding ace-king. For reasons of space and simplicity I had to omit Williams from the account in the article. I also omitted the suits of the cards.
  • Dan Harrington is a fascinating character. He excels at chess, backgammon, and finance as well as poker, and he wrote a very popular series of books on hold'em poker with Bill Robertie (himself a chess master and two-time world backgammon champion). He won the World Series of Poker main event in 1995. After his successful squeeze play in 2004 he wound up finishing fourth. He had finished third the year before.
Some people have noted that this could not have been the very first squeeze play bluff ever in poker. And of course it wasn't. But it was, in my opinion, the most influential squeeze play. Because ESPN revealed the players' hole cards, it was verifiably a squeeze play. As I hinted in the article, without the hole card cameras, everyone watching the hand would have assumed that Harrington had a big hand when he raised. Even if Harrington had said later that he had a six-deuce, some people wouldn't have believed him, and no one could have been sure. Once ESPN showed this hand (and Harrington wrote about it in his second Harrington on Hold'em volume), every serious player became aware specifically of the squeeze play strategy, and generally of the value of re-raising "light" before the flop. And because the solid, thinking man's player Dan Harrington did it, they knew it wasn't just the move of a wild man like Stu Ungar, but a key part of a correct, balanced strategy.

Of course, the squeeze play doesn't work every time. It would have failed here if Arieh (or Raymer) really did have big hands themselves. Harrington probably had a "read" that suggested they weren't that strong, but I think this read would have been based much more on his feel for the overall flow of the game—noticing how many pots they were playing, whether they had shown down weak hands before—than on any kind of physical or verbal tell.

Two years after Harrington's squeeze play, Vanessa Selbst was a bit embarrassed on ESPN when she tried to re-squeeze a squeezer she figured she had caught in the act. At a $2000 WSOP preliminary event final table, she open-raised with five-deuce, and drew a call followed by a raise: the exact pattern of the squeeze play. After some thought she went all-in, but the putative squeezer held pocket aces. Selbst was out in 7th place. But she didn't stop playing aggressively, and since then she has become one of the top all-time money winners, and most respected players in poker. Most of the hand is shown in the video below, starting at about the 6:50 mark.


Some readers of the column asked whether I wasn't just describing a plain old bluff, the defining play of poker (at least in the popular mind). The answer is that the squeeze play is a particular kind of bluff—indeed, a kind of "pure bluff," which is a bluff in which your own hand had zero or close to zero chance of actually wining on its merits. (A "semi-bluff," by contrast, is a bluff when you figure to have the worst hand at the time of the bluff, but your hand has a good chance of improving to be the best hand by the time all the cards are out.) What the Harrington hand showed is a particular situation in which a pure bluff is especially likely to work. Pros don't bluff randomly, or when they feel like it, or even when they think they have picked up a physical tell. And they especially don't bluff casually when more than one opponent has already entered the hand. Harrington's bluff was more than just a bluff: It was a demonstration of how elite players exploit their skills to pick just the right spots to bluff and get away with it.

In future columns I’ll talk about different games, hopefully with something interesting to say about each one. The next column should appear in the December 6–7 issue, and will probably concern the world chess championship. My “tryout” could end at any time, of course, but for now my column should be in that same space once per month, at a length of about 450 words. As most of you know, it’s a challenge to say something meaningful in so few words, and for me it’s a challenge just to stay within that word limit while saying anything at all. As in poker, I may need a bit of luck.

By the way, I think it's too bad that the New York Times decided to end their chess column last month. I believe, or at least hope, that there is a market for regular information on games like chess for people who don't pay so much attention via other websites and publications. I remember reading Robert Byrne's version of the Times column in the 1970s. I would get especially excited when my father came home on one of the days the column ran, so that I could grab his newspaper and check it out. Yes, it used to run at least three times per week, then two, then just on Sundays (when Dylan McClain took over with a different, and I think better, approach from Byrne's). Now it doesn't run at all. The Washington Post ended its column as well, but some major newspapers still have one (The Boston Globe and New York Post come to mind).

PS: If you liked the squeeze play column, here are some of my other pieces on games that you can read online, in reverse chronological order:

"The Science of Winning Poker" (WSJ, July 2013)

"Should Poker Be (A Tiny Bit) More Like Chess?" (this blog, August 2013)

"Chess Championship Results Show Powerful Role of Computers" (WSJ, November 2013)

"Bobby Fischer Recalled" (WSJ, March 2009)

"It's Your Move" (WSJ, October 2007)

"How Chess Became the King of Games" (WSJ, November 2006)

"The Other American Game" (WSJ, July 2005)

"A Match for All Seasons" (WSJ, December 2002)

"Checkmate for a Champion" (WSJ, November 2000)

101 comments:

  1. Travelers have since quite a while ago weeped over the shoe-calfskin hamburger served in even the best of Europe's eateries. Presently the Continent is turning out tasty cuts even a ruler would support.
    thesis writing service

    ReplyDelete
  2. Much appreciated, Also check this one http://www.b2bmarketing.net/blog/posts/2015/10/28/developing-efficient-b2b-content-marketing-strategy-%E2%80%93-10-steps I've quite recently been scanning for data about this theme for some time and yours is the best I've happened upon till now. Be that as it may, what concerning the primary concern? Is it accurate to say that you are certain as to the supply?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Column at Wall Street Journal: can't imagine a significantly bigger success! I would appreciate some feedback on one of my first accepted article: Most Common College Writing Mistakes. I hope one day to get a column at some well-known website.

    ReplyDelete
  4. People can imagine how cumbersome it can get to complete a dissertation for academic purpose. It is easier said than done, when it comes to concisely noting down your thoughts. This is when a professional service can be of profound importance as they can provide with accurately written material in a given time frame. Possibly, such services are better suited for the job as they have been doing it for quite some time and also provide you quality outcome. As dissertation and essays form a vital part of the academic life, any student or researcher will find it worthwhile to acquire the services of experts.for more details clcick here - Dissertation UK

    ReplyDelete
  5. A final year graduate or a particular degree aspirer, every other student has this one particular nightmare to write their dissertations before the completion of their particular course. Though it may seem an easy task, but in reality, writing a good dissertation requires certain proper ideas and skills. Dissertation Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  6. Student life has become quite difficult owing to immense pressure from the tough college and university syllabi. A student has so many papers to write on tough subjects and hectic topics. A student also finds it hectic to go through all the necessary authentic sources required to complete the coursework. One cannot concentrate on writing a thorough researched paper in such circumstances. The fear of failure makes matters worse. Academic Writing Service can come to your aid here.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Colleges and Universities require students to submit their coursework with the highest quality. This requires a lot of research work on behalf of the students. Coursework Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  8. We deal into custom coursework writing service. Best Coursework Help Available. Buy Coursework now at reasonable prices.Thanks for | Coursework Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  9. I liked your article very much. You have portrayed it well by giving hints etc. I want to write a paper in such impressive way. For that i need expert help. do i get help from dissertation writing service UK.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The team at College Homework Help is a well qualified group of tutors with mostly PhDs from best Universities.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is an expert writers’ and tutors’ group which assures you in guidance of educational and business writings of 100% plagiarism free.College Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  12. The key to better scores at Universities or colleges is submission of original coursework. Students find it a tad difficult to cope up with the pressure to write various papers for many subjects and topics.Home page for | Coursework Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  13. Get History Essay Help, Research Papers, Dissertation and Thesis by expert Writers at very Reasonable prices. All are our tutors/writers are full time and we have 24/7 work environment so that you never miss any next deadline.go for History Essay Help

    ReplyDelete
  14. Are you looking for Dissertation Writing Help? Our writers can help you round the clock. Contact us for best grades. Hire Professional Writers at most reasonable Prices. Dissertation Writing Services || Dissertation Writing Help

    ReplyDelete
  15. Fantastic one. Very interesting post. i really enjoyed a lot.It is a new information for me. Thanks for sharing this type of information.Dissertation Writing Services Reviews help you to write perfect journal.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Christopher Chabris,
    Very nice and informative article you have shared here on GAME ON — My New Column in the Wall Street Journal. I read in detail and got very required information as such kind of information from Rushessay.com . Thanks for your excellent sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  17. best gaming headset 2016 Players can get to the administration over the web utilizing just their Broadband association, which implies that this innovation has really upset the way PC diversions are played.

    ReplyDelete
  18. The columnist makes different writing. People love to read their column and wait for latest episode. The change from rotting towards some game column is also liked by people through essay service review. The change also works for the people. This leads people for best information. The learning and updating knowledge is important for people.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Well Thanks a lot for such a wonderful post, the stuff posted were really interesting and useful. The quality of the content was good and clear.
    electrical engineering tutors

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going.... I really enjoyed exploring your site.
    IFRS Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  21. well Thanks a lot for such a wonderful post, the stuff posted were really interesting and useful. The quality of the content was good and clear.
    EViews Online Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  22. MATLAB Homework Help
    Incredible post and I figure I'm likewise a devotee of web journal remarking as it has various advantages.

    ReplyDelete
  23. That's the very nice post you have shared with us. I really liked it. Please keep sharing more and more information.
    Value of Market Research Help

    ReplyDelete
  24. A good writing assignment is a daunting task for the students as it involves indepth thinking, a tough topic/concept and critically detailed research and knowledge.
    Write My Essay | Write My Essay For Me | Accounting Homework Help | Finance Homework Help | Statistics Homework Help | Economics Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  25. It's just a wonderful article! People who play poker will understand you. I ordered a similar review on this site https://99papers.com/ and I deserve the attention of many gamers.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Such documents need to study and draw conclusions. It's like reading a book, and then to write a review about it. I recently started to practice this type of activity, but it was all to no avail. I continued my student activities here, check the link. It brings a lot of money if you know how to beautifully and correctly disclose the questions.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I have express a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging.
    downlodable keygens

    ReplyDelete
  29. La nuova versione di iMortacci porta dei miglioramenti in termini di bug fixing. downlodable software The first and only app that lets you show off your incredible sports prognostication skills.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Finally I found a great post with interesting topic. I read every points of this post that is really so enjoyable and I have bookmark your site for get back again here.
    1 Yonge Condos

    ReplyDelete
  31. Blog mBankV klasickm internetovm bankovnictv si mete nastavit limity pro jednorzov pevody na ty v rmci R. My page. There is no fascination with death being pandered here.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Cool colors and very pleasant sound make this a unique gaming experience. download software We are here for you and look forward to hearing from you! Roadside Services Get help on the road with 21st Roadside assistance.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Select a channel you want to watch on live TV from the channel list. download videos The only thing standing between you and victory are endless clones that follow the path you've traveled.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Amy Burns is a Gypsy with a gift: she can name a person's One True Love. This link : A partir del lanzamiento del nuevo IPhone 3G, Clarin.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Weve added modern content and synonyms for new words such as epiphany & stakeholder, plus 30,000 more new entries. download files A trophy shelf for each child displays their earned trophies.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Tap on an event title anywhere to open it in FlowNote. Find it here Sofia's Ocean was created with these questions in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Destinations Browse through Flickr photographs taken at your destinations. download tv shows If you're learning Spanish then this program is extremely useful.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Well I would like to congratulate to you amazing writing skills as a regular member of your blog I wanted to say this, it’s really informative blog good work!
    SEO Company Jacksonville

    ReplyDelete
  39. StyleVid: Homemade Clothing is part of the StyleVid series of iPhone Applications. link for you Retro dads bark orders like "Do as I say, not as I do!" and Dont make me come back there.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Make sure to get appropriate vaccinations before going overseas. downlodable activation codes So, crash those orbs as fast as you can, collect those stars and keep track of your performance with built-in stats.

    ReplyDelete
  41. This information here will surely be of some help to me : usefull site

    ReplyDelete
  42. - Fixed a bug that caused the app to show blank, greyed-out photos on some phones. downlodable files Start aiming at the target by moving your iPhone/iPod touch.

    ReplyDelete
  43. http://klinikfarma.com/
    http://roommanis.com/
    http://obataborsi-ampuh.com/

    ReplyDelete
  44. Save your Collage of Web Browsers as a bookmark, and load it whenever you want. psicomagia de alejandro jodorowsky pdf StopDebljino is the first Croatian application for weight loss and weight control.

    ReplyDelete
  45. In brief, Tyson told several audiences that President Bush said the words "Our God is the God who named the stars" in his post-9/11 speech in order to divide Americans from Muslims. Sean Davis, a writer for the website The Federalist, pointed out that Bush never said these exact words, and that the closest words he actually said were spoken after the space shuttle explosion in 2003 as part of a tribute to the astronauts who died

    ReplyDelete
  46. Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.
    Assignment Help Canada

    ReplyDelete
  47. HOW QUOTATIONS, AFFIRMATIONS AND ACTION STEPS CAN MAKE YOU RICH AND ENRICH YOUR LIFEThe power is in the quote. ensoniq eps manual pdf There are a lot of options to customizing this reader application.

    ReplyDelete
  48. We are fully able to help you in the thesis assignment, you can get help from any type of thesis assignment from us.

    ReplyDelete
  49. There are so many types of sewing machines starting from traditional machines to electric machines and from electronic ones to computerized sewing machines

    ReplyDelete
  50. Hello friend, your all blog is very useful for everyone, I really like your all post. Thanks for sharing your experience with us and this type of information. I hope you will continue to this sharing with us.

    Get Ayurvedic Medicines For Kidney Damage in India

    ReplyDelete
  51. I have read your column and it showed that you have best experience and knowledge as well to possess different things. From all of my dissertation proposal writing service team, I would like to appreciate you to sharing the link of your article.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Married to a multi-millionaire rap mogul, she is known as the White Sister. http://equipmentauto.ru This version fixes the launch crashes that happened with some devices, enjoy!

    ReplyDelete
  53. Awesome Work, I like the helpful info you provide in your articles, you touched some nice factors here and you have a genuine capacity for composing extraordinary Stuff. It is a perfect work and it's really inspiring and full fill with knowledge.
    http://ola.coop.br/lakeshoreblvd/blog/95-lake-shore-blvd-condo-project-the-new-project-of-toronto

    ReplyDelete
  54. Strum and pick chords (3 notes make a chord - watch demo video on website) 4. downloadfastplease.me About page modified and separated into different sections.

    ReplyDelete
  55. thanks for the nice blog. i'm very happy i found this blog. thank you
    Online Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  56. Currently in the process of re-submitting the app with the latest development tool. download torrent Story: A long time ago in a far away land there dwelt a lone sheet of paper.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Their only solace is in placing blame on each other for their own evolutionary shortcomings. http://topdownloadtorrentfast.us Easy words are mostly one-syllable and some very common two-syllable words.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Are you need term paper help at this time, contact with MyAssignemnthelp.com, they offer term paper help online for 100+ subjects.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Christopher Chabris thank you sharing that important information with video. Your Video helping me to understand that information.
    Accounting Case Study help

    ReplyDelete
  60. R u looking for buy assignments singapore services, than hire our expert singapore assignment writer

    ReplyDelete
  61. Students who are in USA can now get a good quality essay help paper from MyAssignmenthelp.com. It is guaranteed to customers that the papers that they give meet the high university standards.
    myassignmenthelp.com/us/essay-help.html

    ReplyDelete
  62. If you love Numerology, you can help us by rating us 5 Stars in the iTunes App Store. download music And when you're ready to go out, quick integration with Maps will have you at your destination in no time.

    ReplyDelete
  63. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Are you searching who can write my custom essay in USA? Then contact with MyAssignmenthelp.com, this one of the best source for providing essay writing services in USA.

    ReplyDelete
  65. From dreipol GmbH: Prepare for a relentless, unforgiving and addicting arcade experience. downloadfreefileshere.top This update improves support for iOS 8, iPhone 6, and iPhone 6 Plus.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Button activation timing can be adjusted to meet the needs and capabilities of the user. downloadingnow.top "Idea Generator can get you thinking your way out of an envelope.

    ReplyDelete
  67. Dissertation help services have been one of the most frequently requested services at MyAssignmenthelp.com, and with time, the need for such assistance has increased considerably among the students.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Our essay help online service is proficient in providing top quality essays in every academic field. Experienced writers develop each essay from scratch after precise and in-depth planning to provide quality essay assignment help.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Hire our assignment writer for online Assignment Help at reasonable price. We deliver assignment writing work at desire time.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Avail instant homework help at discounted rate from top ranked Homework Helper who are highly qualified and having deep knowledge in their relative fields. Click on SingaporeAssignmentHelp.com to get prompt and reliable homework help support from our extraordinary writers.

    ReplyDelete
  71. Online assignment help for students====>>>www.bestassignmentexperts.com

    ReplyDelete
  72. It is a new way for people to easily discover new games and easily access ... of Facebook Games Arcade appeared in the right-hand column during ... My Games, or games on the Facebook platform that the user already plays
    dissertation Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  73. Online Writing help for students===>>>www.bestassignmentexperts.com

    ReplyDelete
  74. Wow! What better information is this. Thank you so much for sharing. Your blog make me feel so much better. I really enjoyed reading your post and you are giving better mobile Learning Content. Writing is giving the guidelines about the essay writing for academic work. college essay writing tips

    ReplyDelete
  75. Nice blog, your work is great and I hope for some more nice posts. Continue writing such a nice blog. It’s hard to discover fantastic composition like yours nowadays. And also here I got new ideas and guidelines. Thank you so much for your great sharing. Academic Writing Style

    ReplyDelete
  76. We honestly want to serve you the simplest matters with 100 percentage satisfactions. It is extraordinarily exhausting to say as soon as exactly must be forced to money your test. Usually it http://www.unitedcheckcashing.com ought to terribly tough to cash if it is now not official hours.check casher

    ReplyDelete
  77. - New levels: play 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7 hands simultaneously. downlodable driver To go back to default results just press Clear Filters.

    ReplyDelete
  78. I like your blog and the posts over it. Truly logo configuration has its own particular constructive outcome on business if its great and infectious one.Research paper topics 

    ReplyDelete
  79. Bestassignmentexperts.com provides essay help in very unique and innovative way and we are bound to deliver best service for our students

    ReplyDelete
  80. online essay assignment help for students===>>>www.bestassignmentexperts.com

    ReplyDelete
  81. Hire our Expert Writers at students assignment help for Assignment Help Australia at low price and achieve excellent grades. More than 3000 writers from UK, Singapore and USA are available to write your assignment.

    ReplyDelete
  82. URL Rediscover: Starting from discovered URLs, find new URLs on related pages. downloadgtasanandreas.me From Think-Grow Management: With more than 64,000 books on leadership on amazon.

    ReplyDelete
  83. Furniture Moving Company
    Furniture is one of the things that we can do a lot of effort and time in order to carry out transportation from one place to another, to any place in the Kingdom or anywhere outside the Kingdom. The transport works from services that seem to us easy and simple but ultimately Of the services that lead to exposure to problems is very difficult to be solved from the breakage, scratching, damage and loss, the company tops the excellence of the most important and best companies that achieve the highest level of transport services for furniture and the agreement with the Gulf Cooperation Center in order to maintain the furniture against Any problem, if you are puzzled by the matter of purity We are sure that you now have the best companies specialized in transportation by relying on providing a number of distinguished services.
    شراء الاثاث المستعمل بحائل

    ReplyDelete
  84. Students from dublin can take help from the experts of Ireland assignment help which is the top-class a
    Urgent assignment help Dubin services company in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  85. Great post yet I was thinking about whether you could compose a litte more on this subject? I"d be exceptionally grateful in the event that you could expound a tad bit further. Value it! Ocean Of Games

    ReplyDelete
  86. Assignment services are provided by the irelandassignmenthelp.com which is the best writing services in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  87. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  88. Wow, this is quite amazing. I think it would be that many people still find these stories.


    m8bet

    m8bet

    บาคาร่า

    ReplyDelete
  89. The max number of shots is limited by iPhone, iPod Touch & iPad2 available memory space. downlodable ebooks It syncs with the web application in the background.

    ReplyDelete
  90. Students Assignment Help provides food the best assignment help services on the planet. Our Assignment Writers are Qualified from top colleges. They give the best Assignment Services at the least expensive cost.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.